Extra! Extra! Read All About It: Psyching Out at #1, Sales Up by 400%, and a Glowing Review in The Wall Street Journal

I’ve received enough amazing news lately from my publisher and beyond that I thought it’s time for an update here. How have things been going with the debut, you ask? Well, friends, let me tell you.

At launch, The Extra hit #1 on Ingram’s sales charts in a couple of categories: psychological horror and sci-fi. All of science ficiton. (!) In fact, it’s STILL #1 on Ingram’s Psychological Horror charts! (I will resist discussing genre for now, but to give you a broad perspective, Goodreads readers have shelved it most commonly in these terms: horror, science fiction, novella, thriller, fiction, mystery, audiobook, adult, suspense, favorites :D)

In the less than two months since release (September 9th), The Extra sales have increased nearly 400% over launch day sales totals! That means the magic thing that all authors hope for: word is spreading. People are talking. The book is gaining traction after launch rather than losing steam.

My publisher also shared that The Extra is nearing Shortwave’s Top 5 All-Time Bestsellers list. This is stellar news not just because I want the book to do well for my sake (duh), but also because I want it to be successful for my publisher! They’ve taken a huge chance on me, a debut, with not one but THREE novellas in The Outsiders Sequence, so this is validating and encouraging.

And in a plot twist I never saw coming, The Wall Street Journal reviewed The Extra in their paper (digital and print!!) with glowing praise. Some highlights:

“Annie Neugebauer’s The Extra offers a short, sharp shock; a combination of logistical and existential dread makes it feel like a much longer (and more frightening) experience.”

“Ms. Neugebauer is a poet and speculative-fiction writer who is no stranger to tales of horror. With The Extra she has written a nearly perfect, claustrophobic novella with a very effective countdown clock.”

“If you have time for only one terrifying tale this spooky season, make room for The Extra.”

All of this feels overwhelming, surreal, and slightly unbelievable to me as I gather it together for a blog update. It may not be an instant international bestseller, but damn, this is good stuff. Some more odds and ends to share:

I joined in on Next Chapter Bookseller’s Bookstore Horror Day here in Minneapolis–Saint Paul this weekend, and I sold out of The Extra before my hour was up! I met so many cool readers, tabled with fellow Shortwave author Patrick Barb, and had a blast. If you’re in the Twin Citities, be sure to check out Next Chapter.

My dear longtime writing friend and critique partner Lisa Bubert hosted me in her wonderful newsletter sharing some more behind-the-scenes writerly stuff about The Extra, including submission stats! If you’re not already subscribed to Lisa’s newletter, go sign up!

We broke through 100 written reviews on Goodreads and are well over 300 ratings! 50 on Amazon. Only a couple on Barnes & Noble. We need more everywhere! If you’ve enjoyed the book, please do consider copy-pasting a sentence or two saying why into your favorite sites. It really helps new readers take the leap.

Other free ways to help boost the book: mention it at your local bookstores. Request it through your library. Talk about it with your friends. Suggest it for your book club. Share posts online. So many of you have already done so much of this, and all I can say is thank you. It’s helping!!

I had a fabulous launch party. I’ve seen my book on library shelves. I’ve seen my book on bookstore shelves. I’ve seen my book with a shelf talker. I’ve signed my book for readers who’ve read it and loved it. Basically, I’m having the time of my life and savoring every single second of this ride. I have no idea what the future holds, but right now this part of things is an absolute blast.

Thank you to everyone who is celebrating with me, boosting the signal, and, of course, reading the book! I’m so grateful for you all.

Share this:
Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail
Posted in Updates & Announcements | Tagged | 2 Comments

Activate Launch Day: THE EXTRA Has Arrived

Why is it that days that feel like they’ll never get here always end up sneaking up on you?

Today is the day my first book officially releases, although for weeks now support and early reads and reviews have been rolling in like a tidal wave of joy. And now the day–9/9–is finally here and I am swept away in it. Truly, it feels like a dream come true.

It all started with a high concept idea. What if, instead of someone going missing, there was an extra?

Ten people head out on a backpacking trip,
but the first night eleven set up camp.
Everyone remembers everyone else.
Who is the extra?

Well, that idea has grown up to become my debut book, a novella called The Extra that you can now buy wherever you buy your books. Paperback direct from my publisher, ebook, audiobook from Audible (narrated by the talented Sean Patrick Hopkins), or ordered from most major chains or independent bookstores!

Not sold yet? Here’s what some award-winning and bestselling authors have to say:

And reviewers:

Want to know what you’re getting into, exactly? Here’s what you’ll find inside:

And if you’re thinking that a slim little novella just isn’t enough, you’re in luck, because The Extra is book #1 in The Outsiders Sequence, a trilogy of shared-world novellas. The Other comes out next year, and The Spare in 2027, so make sure you get your copy of The Extra now.

I would love so much if you’d join us to celebrate at the virtual launch party tomorrow night (Wednesday) at 6pm CST. You can come whether you’ve read the book yet or not, or even upgrade your free ticket to one that includes a personalized print copy mailed to you. It will include readings by the audiobook narrators, Q&A, and a teaser of book #2! It’s being hosted by my wonderful publisher Alan Lastufka and fantastic agent Alec Shane, and it’s going to be a blast! Just look at this crew!

And last but not least, if you’re a writer who’s been following me on my blog, or anyone who’s intersted in the “behind the scenes” of the writing life, I’m back as a guest today at my old stomping grounds Writer Unboxed sharing this book’s surprising journey with “You Don’t Choose Your Train.” How lovely to be so warmly welcomed back.

Thank you so much to everyone who’s helping make this debut special. It means the whole damn world.

Share this:
Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail
Posted in Uncategorized, Updates & Announcements | Leave a comment

You Are Cordially Invited

Somehow, in the midst of moving across the country and all manner of global chaos and personal upheaval, release day for my debut book is right around the corner. My novella The Extra is officially out in the world on September 9th, although subscribers to Shortwave’s quarterly book box have already gotten theirs, and pre-orders direct from the publisher tend to ship out early, and advance review copies have been floating around for weeks now…

Feeling left out? It’s not too late to get your pre-order in before we drop that “pre.” If you order direct, your copy will come with fun swag goodies while supplies last: a signed book plate (autographed sticker) and a custom coordinating bookmark. It’s also available for preorder wherever you normally buy your books, including the audiobook on Audible! (Sean Patrick Hopkins knocks it out of the park with his reading.)

As I mentioned, my family recently (as in less than a month ago) moved from Texas to Minnesota, so I am in a brand new state with no writing connections and am still living out of boxes. Still, though, this is something I’ve been looking forward to for years, so we’re going to make time to celebrate. And I would love nothing more than if you could join me.

It’s a virtual launch party! On Wednesday September 10, 7pm EST (that’s 6pm central for my Texan folks), my fantastic publisher Alan Lastufka of Shortwave Publishing is hosting a Zoom event to celebrate the release of The Extra. Talk about going above and beyond. Alan is amazing. My literary agent Alec Shane will be co-hosting, and in attendance will be the stellar audiobook narrator duo Sean Patrick Hopkins and Patricia Santomasso, along with some other special guests, like authors Tanya Pell and Clay McLeod Chapman (who generously blurbed the book). My dearest critique partners will be there, and (I hope) as many family members, friends, readers, writers, followers, interested people, and whoever else would like to pop in as can make it.

We’ll have Q&A, live readings, and all kinds of fun. It should be a great time. I would love, love, love if you’d come too. It’s free to register through EventBrite, unless you’d like to upgrade to a personalized print copy of the novella that I will sign and mail out after the event. (There’s even an option to buy the sold-out Q4 book box from Shortwave!!) You are welcome to come whether you’ve read the book yet or not!

In case you missed it, the shared-world novellas being published by Shortwave now have a series title: The Outsiders Sequence. The Extra is book #1, and there might be a little sneak peek of The Other (book #2) during the event. 🙂

Questions? Requests? Drop them in the comments. And please reserve your spot for the event on Wednesday, 9/10/25 for a fun evening to help me celebrate this milestone. I hope to see you there!

Share this:
Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail
Posted in Updates & Announcements | Leave a comment

Release Swaps, Early Praise, and a New Story

Some news about the publication of my books! The publisher of my collection, Bad Hand Books, has signed a major distribtuion deal with Baker & Taylor, which is a huge win for me and their other authors; it means our books will appear in bookstores and libraries all over North America! This win does mean some adjustments, though, like shifting the release dates of several of their titles, inlcuding mine.

So You Have to Let Them Bleed will now release in the first quarter of 2026. If you’ve already preordered it (thank you!), everything is still good to go; it will ship upon release with a signed bookplate. If you’ve haven’t ordered it yet, please do! Direct from my publisher will include an autographed book sticker while supplies last. And everyone can also add it to your “want to read” shelf on Goodreads now.

What this means, if you’re keeping track, is that my novella The Extra will now be releasing first! The Extra releases on September 9th this year–so just about four months away! If you don’t yet have that one lined up to ship as soon as it’s out, you can preorder The Extra direct from Shortwave to also receive a signed bookplate and extra swag goodies while supplies last. (You can add The Extra on Goodreads too!)

If you like behind-the-scenes type stuff, like me unboxing my print copies of my first two books, be sure you’re following me on Instagram @AnnieNeugebauer. That’s where I’m most active online. You’ll also see author blurbs praising The Extra and You Have to Let Them Bleed on Instagram (as well as on my book pages on my website) as they come in. Highlights so far:

Huge thanks to these incredible (and incredibly busy) authors for reading my books and offering such generous support. It means more than I can say. 🖤

In other news, I have an amazing story acceptance to share! My new short story “We Have Always Been Red” will be in Silent Nightmares: Haunting Stories to Be Told on the Longest Night of the Year, edited by Michael Bailey and Chuck Palahniuk!! It’s quite an honor; mine was 1 of only 6 stories chosen from well over 2,000 submissions. Slush pile for the win! The lineup here is incredible, with some of my favorite authors. Wicked cover. Coming next fall through Saga (Simon & Schuster); more as I hear it!

This is a busy, hectic time for me, but there is so, so much amazing stuff happening. I’m so grateful to everyone who’s supporting me and sharing in the joy! Thank you all!

Share this:
Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail
Posted in Updates & Announcements | Leave a comment

Announcing My Next Two Books: THE OTHER and THE SPARE

What a wild time. I can’t believe I’m here sharing more good news with you, but I’ll take it where I can get it. I’m so, so happy to announce that I’ve sold two more novellas in The Extra universe to the wonderful Shortwave Publishing!!

The image above is the Publishers Marketplace deal announcement (with design fun by Alan Lastufka). Although the formula for PM listings (all one long sentence with a bunch of clauses, code phrases for deal types, etc.) might be baffling for people outside of the book industry, take it from me that many a writer has read the deals every day and dreamed of the time our book(s) would appear there too. It is such a cool feeling. So a quick less-weird way to tell you about these novellas that are in the same universe as The Extra:

The Extra: 10 people head out on a backpacking trip, but 11 set up camp. Everyone remembers everyone else. Who is the extra? (September 9, 2025)

The Other: A couple on an outdoor retreat meet their doppelgangers and soon must put to the test how well they truly know each other. (2026)

The Spare: A young woman is replaced by her nonexistent twin when this spare infiltrates her family’s reunion. (2027)

What a busy few years I’m gearing up for! Thank you so much to everyone who’s making time and energy to celebrate with and support me! And of course, thanks to editor Alan Lastufka for putting faith in me with these two extra titles.

And let’s wrap with one more big happy thing. Huge thanks to Jonathan Maberry, NY Times bestselling author of BURN TO SHINE and COLD WAR (and one of the kindest and most hardworking authors around), for his amazing early blurb for The Extra:

“With THE EXTRA, Annie Neugebauer spins a disturbing tale of paranoia, identity, and horror packed with twists you absolutely won’t see coming! Highly recommended!”

What a dream. It’s my first book blurb ever, and such a thrilling one! I’m so grateful for the excitement around this debut. Line up your copy of The Extra now, and subscribe to my blog to make sure you’re first in line for cover reveals, preorder links for the sequels, and all the good stuff!

Share this:
Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail
Posted in Updates & Announcements | Leave a comment